The entertainment world thrives on rumors, and the latest buzz involving Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster has left fans wondering—did these two stars catch feelings while working together?
While there’s no confirmation of an affair, the situation has sparked a larger conversation about relationships, infidelity, and how love (or lack thereof) grows within a marriage, TheyGossip.com reports.
Enter couples and family therapist Dr. Deb Castaldo, who’s breaking down the dynamics of infidelity and what might actually be happening behind the scenes.
Did Their Connection Go Beyond Broadway?
Actors often develop strong bonds while portraying couples in love—it’s part of the job. Dr. Castaldo acknowledges how this might feel intense.
“One can only imagine how those connections can be intensified when the two people involved are actors portraying a couple in love. After all, they are only human, and it is understandable that an attachment would take hold,” she said.
Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster during rehearsals
It’s important to note that relationships between co-stars don’t automatically cross boundaries.
Castaldo reminds us, “There are all kinds of relationships and love that do not break boundaries and become an affair. There are work friendships, feelings of fondness, and deep connections, especially when people are working together daily.”
Still, fans can’t help but wonder whether Jackman and Foster’s undeniable onstage connection could have grown into something more.
Was an Affair the Cause or the Effect?
Rumors of infidelity often focus on the “what,” but Castaldo urges us to look at the “why.”
“Rarely is an affair the cause of the breakdown of a marriage. Actually, the opposite is common: affairs are often the result of a marriage that has been dysfunctional and unfulfilling for a very long time,” she explains.
For Jackman, his split from wife Deborra-Lee Furness after 27 years shocked fans. If the rumors involving Foster are true, Castaldo suggests it might signal underlying struggles rather than a random betrayal.
“Unless a partner is a serial cheater, infidelity rarely takes place in a vacuum,” she notes. Instead, it’s often the result of “longstanding unresolved issues” or unmet emotional needs.
The Celebrity Factor
For stars like Jackman and Foster, the public scrutiny adds another layer of complexity. “Media scrutiny, the rumor mill, and the negative speculation and criticism of social media adds an extra layer of stress to all parties involved,” Castaldo explains.
Hugh and Sutton/Getty
Imagine trying to navigate your personal feelings while tabloids dissect every glance and interaction. Even if Jackman and Foster’s connection is purely platonic, the constant speculation could create friction in their personal lives.
Can Infidelity Be a Wake-Up Call?
While infidelity often complicates relationships, Castaldo says it can also serve as a turning point.
“Many couples actually do decide to stay together and create a better marriage as a result of the infidelity,” she explains. However, that’s far easier to do in private, without the world weighing in.
If Jackman and Foster’s bond is more than friendship, Dr. Castaldo suggests it’s likely a symptom of deeper unhappiness rather than the root cause of a breakup.
“If so, my guess is an affair was the end result of marriages that deteriorated or individual unhappiness that went unattended, not the cause,” she explains.
The Bigger Picture
While we may never know the full story, the rumors swirling around Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster offer a reminder: relationships need care and attention to thrive.
Hugh and Sutton
“Love does not remain or grow if it is not nurtured and cared for every single day,” says Castaldo.
Whether platonic or romantic, their connection highlights the complexities of love—especially under the spotlight of fame.
For now, Jackman and Foster remain silent on the speculation, leaving fans to wonder if their Broadway connection stayed on stage—or sparked something more.
